Was FDR a Scoundrel?

Summary

Contrary to popular belief, President Franklin D. Roosevelt may not have saved the nation but instead prolonged the Great Depression, with double-digit unemployment persisting until nineteen forty-one. Historian David Bato, in his book 'FDR: A New Political Life,' argues that FDR's experimental New Deal policies like the National Recovery Administration and the AAA were economic disasters, delaying the natural recovery that typically took two to three years. Bato also highlights a lesser-known scandal from FDR's time as assistant secretary of the Navy, where he led an investigation into same-sex relationships, employing spies to entrap naval officers. Furthermore, the book details FDR's alleged 'treachery,' exemplified by his handling of the anti-lynching bill. Despite his wife Eleanor's advocacy and the NAACP's urgent pleas, FDR repeatedly stalled the legislation, even dismissing the issue with laughter when his conservative Vice President showed interest. Bato contends that FDR's priority was maintaining power, not necessarily advancing progressive causes. He also critiques FDR's foreign policy, particularly the demand for unconditional surrender, which he believes unnecessarily lengthened the war and cost countless lives. While acknowledging FDR's skill in politics and his ability to connect with the public through his aristocratic charm and mastery of the radio medium, Bato suggests that many historians are too lenient, overlooking the significant negative aspects of his presidency.